Start here
Compare the fit, finish, installation scope and care you want. Neither material choice removes the need to deal with the existing bathroom correctly.
Explore custom tile showers ↗Where does custom tile offer more choice?
Tile allows you to combine wall sizes, patterns, niches, edges and floor designs around the room. Those choices also add layout and installation work. Custom tile makes sense when the proportions and material character are central to the result you want.
What should you ask about an insert?
Ask which dimensions, colors and accessories are available, what happens to the existing surface and how the enclosure connects to the room. A package price is useful only when you understand its removal, plumbing and repair allowances.
How do you compare the quotes?
Use the same starting condition and desired scope for each provider. Compare demolition, hidden-damage provisions, plumbing, enclosure, preparation and finish work. Installation duration and maintenance instructions should come from the actual system and project rather than broad advertising claims.
A common question
Is tile always more expensive?
The material alone does not settle the total. Room condition, demolition, fixtures, labor and enclosure choices affect both types of project. Compare complete written scopes.